Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Painting the Clearance Post and Lamp

Well, I painted two posts again, the first with two coats of black and then white and the second with silver, black and then white.

It seems that either is sufficient to hide the glowing light from the LED so I think I will recommend two coats of flat black and then the final flat white coat. There did not seem to be any difference in light between the silver and the black painted posts.

Flat or matt paint should be used for coverage as the matt effect is caused by the pigment protruding through the surface of the paint and diverting the light rays in all directions. A gloss paint just has a nice smooth surface and as such does not have as much pigment.

While the paint was drying I went to Jaycar and bought a selection of 1/2 Watt resistors in 2K Ohms, 3K Ohms, 5.1K Ohms and 10K Ohms. I made up a 10K Ohm resistor by putting several in series.

The end result of swapping the resistors around gave the following effects.



1K Ohm resistor - Light flare from lens
1K Ohm resistor - Light shows in 'daylight'
10K Ohm resistor - No light flare from lens
10K Ohm resistor - Lamp appears to be off in 'daylight'

I will recommend that the modeller chooses which resistor to use depending on the preferred effect.

I prefer the 10K resistor as the lamp appears to be off although it is actually on. So back to Jaycar to buy some of the 10K Ohm resistors that I didn't get today, oh well, that's how it goes.






Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Lighting a Clearance Post Lamp

I have had a chance to try lighting a clearance post lamp as discussed in the last post.

I may need to amend the installation painting instructions on the Signals Branch blog as the light from the LED is much brighter than expected and as can be seen in the photo below the light is showing through the paint.

Here is the clearance post lamp lit by a warm white LED. As this was a temporary mounting I added loose ballast around the base for the photo.


This post was painted in black first then white.

Another post painted in silver and then white was actually worse so the silver has less covering power than black.

At the moment the instructions state to use silver then black and finally white but I don't think that the silver adds anything and isn't needed for light transmission either.

I am currently painting another clearance post and lamp with two coats of black and then a white top coat. I will report on this in a day or two as each coat needs to dry thoroughly before the next coat is applied.

The LED is powered from a bridge rectifier running off the DCC track bus. I used a PO4 6A 400V Bridge Rectifier (Jaycar Cat. No. ZR1314) to convert the DCC power to a nominal 12 volts DC. This bridge rectifier has the AC and the + and - terminals clearly marked on it. Also it has a hole through the centre which allows it to be screwed to the layout frame near where the lighting is needed.


I bent the legs out at right angles and screwed them into two terminal blocks at each side as shown in this photo.


The resistance I used for the LED was 2K Ohms which was made by using two 1K Ohm 1/4 Watt resistors in series. I will rewire the LED and resistors and use shrink wrap tubing once I have decided about the resistor value.

The light level could still be a bit lower which could also help to reduce light leakage through the paint. I will have to get a few 5K Ohm 1/4 Watt resistors and see how the light level looks.

I will post the results and amend the instructions accordingly.

Monday, January 19, 2015

NSWGR Clearance Posts with Lamps

I have just added some instructions for clearance posts with lamps to my Signals Branch blog.

Clearance posts with lamps were placed at fouling points of sidings and loops and were painted white for visibility. The lamps were lit at night usually by the Station Assistant and spares would have been kept along with kerosene in the lamp room attached to the men’s toilet.


I have made these in two material types, the White Strong and Flexible for those who may be worried about the posts breaking if hit while cleaning track with a track rubber and Frosted Detail and Frosted Ultra Detail for those who want more detail and who also may wish to have the lamp lit.

If printed in Frosted Detail or Frosted Ultra Detail material they may break if knocked hard (I don't know yet as I have only just installed one), if so then just pull them out and replace with a new one.

These clearance posts with lamps are to be mounted in a 3mm hole drilled through the baseboard at the clearance location of a set of points (turnouts).

The Frosted Detail and Frosted Ultra Detail are an acrylic material which can transmit the light from a 3mm golden white LED placed into their mounting hole from below the baseboard.

Clearance post and lamp in Frosted Ultra Detail - Not lit yet.
Just a quick photo, ballast not yet reinstated around post, being white the detail doesn't show well but the black dot is the hinge of the lamp top and the catch is on the other side.

I have tested it with a torch from below and it gives a small circle of light that would only be seen with the room lights off as you would expect, this is no glaring headlight.

Further details can be found on the Signals Branch blog.

Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Signal Assembly Instructions Update

I have just updated the assembly instructions on the Signals Branch blog.

I did this as a result of currently assembling 16 signals (single posts and brackets).

I amended the drill bit sizes for the fine holes in the White Strong and Flexible (WSF) material and the Fine Ultra Detail (FUD) material. The  drill bit sizes were amended because the WSF expands slightly when drilled so you end up with a smaller hole than the drill bit. As a result the next drill bit size larger than for the FUD is used.

I also added something that I forgot to mention which is that the signal lamps have been designed to take a 0.8mm golden white LED (the ones with 150mm/6 inch leads). Some thoughts are included on wiring.

I haven't installed any 0.8mm LEDs in the signals as I am using Tam Valley Singlet Servos which have Green and RED bi-colour LEDs on the small control board.  The control boards are all under the layout near the servos. I won't be using the push buttons on the control boards to change the signals they will be run from a layout panel on JMRI using some logic. I will probably extend one of the bi-colour LEDs from each control board out to the fascia opposite the signal to show the status.

One problem with semaphore signals on a model railway is that we view the signals from some unusual angles and can't always see the actual arm position. The bi-colour LED will show the arm position for the driver.

If I ever get into night time operations then I will probably install the 0.8mm LEDs in those signals that can be viewed from the front.

Lastly, there are instructions on making clear lenses for the signals and colouring them with Tamiya Clear Red and Clear Blue.

The prototype signals had blue lenses so that the yellow light from the kerosene lamp would show green. This is why a golden white LED should be used, probably at a low light level which will depend on the value of the resistor used.

A statement and an amended date is at the top of the instructions and if there are any further amendments the date will change and I will list the amendments.

Saturday, January 3, 2015

3D Printed Signal Pictures

I  have received a comment about the difficulty of seeing the signals on the very light coloured computer rendition of the signals on my Shapeways shop. Unfortunately I have no control over this as it is part of the Shapeways system. Also there is no zoom which is annoying.

Here are a couple of photos of a distant signal in its raw as received state. Sorry but this is the best I have been able to do, it is very hard to photograph a white object.

Distant Signal Side View

Distant Signal Front View
The 'T' shaped part at the bottom is the main operating crank that is to be cut off the short sprue at the top, placed on the small post behind it and held in place with a small screw (see assembly instructions on the Signals Branch blog).

There is a spare counterweight lever(s) printed on the base of all signals, I left them there from my pilot model just in case the Frosted Ultra Detail ones were fragile but so far they seem to work fine.

Here is a picture of the details parts without the handling protection enclosing framework. The material shows as being clear but it has yet to be rinsed in some acetone to remove a light oil that is used by Shapeways to remove some waxy supporting material from the printing process. Once rinsed in acetone the material goes whitish.

Signal Detail Parts
Here is a view of a completed bracket signal (an early version) showing the operating mechanism below. As you can see from the pictures the main structure of the operating mechanism is printed as part of the signal. The mechanism is designed to fit in a 20mm (single arm posts) or a 22mm (multiple arm post) hole in the baseboard. The mechanism has also been designed to be within the depth of a baseboard construction of 13mm board plus 2" x 1" (what is that in mm?) frame.


Early Version Bracket Signal
The silver screws adjust the throw of the signal arms and the large operating crank absorbs the mechanical throw protecting the delicate signal arms and rods above. Please note that the heads of the two silver screws interfere with each other so I suggest the use of 8BA or 2-56 screws (see the assembly instructions for more detail). I have used some of those black acetal plastic Kadee screws with success (and I have a heap collected won the years).

Here is a picture showing a two arm outer home and distant signal and two Tam Valley servo motors mounted underneath the baseboard. I like the Tam Valley Singlet servos as they are relatively cheap, include a DCC accessory decoder on the control board, have an auto adjusting feature for the throw and are easy to install.

Two Servo Motors Driving Two Signal Arms
Here is a video just to show that it works.


And another video showing the down loop starter at Wollar, yes I know some like to call it an inner home or some such.... ;-)


Til next time.


Friday, January 2, 2015

Signals Branch

As promised I have just opened my Shapeways shop online and it is known as Signals Branch. I have added it to a list of links on the right side of this blog.

I hope that you get some value from the design work I have done over the last six months.

Be aware that the prices quoted on the Shapeways site are in US$ and that any order you place will be converted to AU$.

Please read the welcome post which can be accessed on the right hand side of the Signals Branch blog. It would be nice if it could remain at the top of the posts but there doesn't seem to be facility for this.

Enjoy!

Monday, December 29, 2014

3D Printed NSWGR Lower Quadrant Signals

In my last post I mentioned that I will be releasing a number of NSWGR signal 'kits' through an online shop at Shapeways, an on demand 3D printing company located in both Eindhoven, The Netherlands and also New York, USA. Australian print orders have recently been allocated to the New York facility.

The signal posts have been designed to be printed in the Shapeways White Strong and Flexible material (WSF).

The White Strong and Flexible material is a laser sintered nylon which has a low print resolution but is quite strong and flexible. The flexibility is of advantage for a signal on a layout as it will actually bend a bit if knocked or if it is caught by clothing when someone reaches over the layout.

One disadvantage of 3D printing is that for each material there are minimum tolerances for printing, such as minimum wall thickness, minimum supported wire (rods or other small cross sections), minimum unsupported wires, minimum detail size, etc. As a result the finer details sometimes have to be enlarged to be printable and for that matter, even to be seen.

By choosing to use the White Strong and Flexible material the ladder and railings are thicker than would be found in an etched signal kit. If wire railings are preferred then the printed ones may be cut off and wire ones substituted in fine holes that will need to be drilled at the previous signal attachment points. Similarly, the existing ladders could be cut away and etched ladders may also be added. Be aware though that the nylon is tough and doesn’t cut easily even with a sharp hobby knife. A pair of new transistor snips could be used where there is access. Transistor snips are ground flat on one side of the cutting edges so they can be pressed against a surface to give a reasonably smooth flat cut.

The upside of the printing process is that other parts may be of a more correct thickness and have detail such as the cast iron support under the beams of a bracket signal. In an etched signal this support is usually just a thin brass shape. You will also find that there are individual boards on the platforms with gaps that can be seen through.

The White Strong and Flexible material is nylon which doesn’t normally glue or take paint well, in this case however, due to the laser sintered fine particles there is a very good key for both glue and paint. The preferred glue is Super Glue (ACC – cyanoacrylate) and acrylic water based paints also work well, enamels can be used as well but the acrylics are usually a bit thicker which can assist in sealing and smoothing the surface of the White Strong and Flexible material.

The signal arms and other detail parts of the signals are printed in the Shapeways Frosted Ultra Detail material (FUD). The Frosted Ultra Detail material is an acrylic resin which is printed by using a ultra-violet light to set the resin layer by layer. This material will give a high print resolution but is hard and somewhat brittle, a disadvantage when knocked.

The Signal Posts

I have uploaded 3D models for the following signals:

16' post - 1 Signal arm.
18' post - 1 Signal arm
18' post - 2 Signal arms
23' post - 1 Signal arm
23' post - 2 Signal arms
23' post - 3 Signal arms
27' post - 1 Signal arm
27' post - 2 Signal arms
27' post - 3 Signal arms
27' post - 1 Signal arm + Lamp above (Distant Signal)
27' post Bracket Signal - Right Hand lower Signal arm
27' post Bracket Signal - Left Hand lower Signal arm
27' post Bracket Signal - Right Hand - Even height Signal arms
27' post Bracket Signal - Left Hand - Even height Signal arms
Centre post Bracket Signal - Right Hand lower Signal arm
Centre post Bracket Signal - Left Hand lower Signal arm
Centre post Bracket Signal - Even height Signal arms
Offset Bracket - Right Hand 1 Signal arm
Inverted Bracket - Right Hand 1 Signal arm
27' post Triple Bracket - Centre post highest - Left and Right lower at same height.

Some example renders of signals:

Close up of detail on bracket signal

Coloured left hand bracket

27' post with 3 signal arm positions

Centre post bracket with even height dolly posts

Right hand offset bracket

Triple bracket
 
Inverted bracket
To overcome some problems printing the ladders I have had to add some ladder supports which will need to be removed with transistor nippers as shown in the following image.

The 'Y' shaped ladder supports are to be removed.
Detail Parts
 
To complement the above signal selection I have designed and uploaded a number of signal arm and detail part 'sprues'.

I have tried to cover various combinations of signal arms with these 'sprues'.

The following signal arms will be available in various combinations:

39 1/4" arms - Main line
36" arms - Main line
30" arms - Passing and crossing loops
Siding arms
Shunt Ahead arms
Wrong Road arms


Standard Bracket set

Distant set

Siding and Shunt Ahead set

39" and 36" arms set

Inverted Bracket set
Centre post Bracket set
Spares set
Siding and Wrong Road
Some of the above are also available as double sets.
 
The above detail sets will come with a frame around them to hopefully stop any parts breaking off the sprue during cleaning and handling post-printing. If a part does break off the sprue it usually means that the print is rejected as the person handling the item doesn't know that the part has just broken away from a sprue, they think that the item is broken. Shapeways will re-print the item at their cost in this case which can delay the delivery. Unfortunately, if the item keeps breaking they will reject the item and withdraw it from sale. At this point I will be notified to correct the design. Hopefully the frames will stop this from happening.
 
2 x 30" Arms and 2 x Siding Arms set in frame
Extra Items
 
I have also designed a few items that might be of assistance to the modeller:
 
Operating mechanism for use with other signals such as made by Uneek

Type 1 SG90 servo mounting (for servos as used by Tam Valley) - Can be used for points

Type 2 SG90 servo mounting (for servos as used by Tam Valley)

Type 3 SG90 servo mounting (servos as used by Tam Valley) with 'wire in tube' mounting

'Wire in tube' bracket designed to be screwed to any signal operating mechanism
 
Fascia mounting for Tam Valley Singlet control board in white, green or black
Well, that's about the range so far and I am still hoping to open a Shapeways shop in early January.
 
I have been asked about upper quadrant and the tubular lower quadrant signals and I haven't made any decision about those as yet as there are some very different challenges with the tubular posts but who knows.